I saw an item from Fey Handmade in a magazine today, and I went to the site out of curiosity and love it. The prices are a mix of high and low, but the items look really special and Etsy-esque (it's a word now).
I think the photography prints are my favorites...
I also like these things for the house (one day)...
Pebble Beach Cushion Cover
And I find this stuff just cute and quirky...
Bleu Finch Clutch